The Journey of the Lebanese Curriculum: A Review of Research

Technology has been affecting the development of most sectors of life,namely industrial, medical, scientific, and among others. It has  also been enhancing the educational system to help us cope with everything new. Thus, it is expected to have an updated curriculum that fits the students’ needs from time to time. 

This is not the case in Lebanon. 

According to the Ministry of Education and Higher Education in Lebanon (MEHE), the Lebanese educational system hasn’t been officially updated since 1997. Akl showed in her study conducted at the University of Malta that the inhibitors of progression of the educational system are the several wars Lebanon has gone through such as the civil war that lasted 15 years. 

Similar to any other country in the world, Lebanese schools are divided into two sectors: public schools and private ones.  The systems suffer from many problems related to the way of delivering the material to students, the level of interaction between the students and their teachers, lack of technologies, and online teaching alternatives. A study by Hashash, Abouchedid, and Abourjeily,  revealed that many different reforms and development strategies were taken to update and to improve the educational system in Lebanon, yet several obstacles are still preventing this development, especially at the public sector level. The following themes are sections associated with the Lebanese educational system:


CERD: Center for Educational Research and Development

CERD is a national association for modernization and improvement of training through instructive planning and strategies. This program was initiated in order to design the curriculum for schools where a number of teachers and professors meet to put all the necessary points. According to Mona Nabhani, Ph.D. in Education and a former participant in CERD, the major problem in this program is the sectarian division. “ For example if we were 13 experts all from different sects and religious backgrounds, but one sect is missing, then they will add this person for the missing sect regardless of their profession in the field,” Nabhani said. She continues to explain that the problem is the absence of a structured and well-organized plan. Nabhani claims that the absence of this plan is due to the differences in philosophies every professor might implement depending on their background. In reference to the study by Awada and Diab, it wasn't until 2013 and under the former Minister of Education Hassan Diab that CERD was forced to plan an advanced curriculum for grades one through three and was accepted by the 2013 Council of Ministers.   


Curriculum Implementation and Assessment

One of the most concerning issues the Lebanese curriculum suffers from is the implementation of fair and equal assessment of the students’ skills. As stated by Awada and Diab, teachers are mainly interested in assessing skills that are tested in the Lebanese Official Examinations. For example, critical thinking and cultural awareness are two of the skills that are not practiced in public schools. Students are treated as machines that only receive information in order to be tested through exams. The majority of schools turn a blind eye on the importance of involving students in activities and introducing them to skills that can meet their targets in the future. In addition, Boujaoude believed the curriculum highlights the importance of teaching the knowledge of science and not “science as a way of knowing." In other words, students should memorize the outcome of science rather than using science to reveal the outcome. Another concerning issue presented by Akl is that the Lebanese curriculum lacks consistent and logical guidelines that could help the students deal with the cultural, political, and religious dilemma; thus, shaping the educational Lebanese system in a limited way. 


Textbooks and Themes

A report written in 2002 by LAES, showed some criticism of the Lebanese curriculum. One of the main criticisms was the equal distribution of themes and goals each grade should fulfill. Accoring to Shaaban's study, some grades have more themes than other grades. Shaaban elaborated that primary grades have 2-6 themes, intermediate grades have 13 themes and grade 10 has around 19 themes. Moving to the language section, the LAES report revealed that the current curriculum does not reflect sufficiently the language requirements, mainly in public schools. This can have many globalization and the importance of the English language nowadays. A difference in negative implications on students’ skills especially with the presence of unlike public ones, prefer to use imported books which they think are better the usage of books was also highlighted in many studies. Private schools, unlike public ones, prefer to use imported books they think are better written. According to Awada and Diab, the local Lebanese textbooks do not meet the professional standards the imported textbooks have. One example is the history book that has not been updated since 1943 due to political the official exams triggers the creativity of students, as stated by disagreements. The former minister Elias Bou Saab stated that neither the books nor the official exams trigger the creativity of students as stated in Awada and Diab’s study.


Student-Teacher Relationship

Abouchedid and his colleagues conducted an experiment that showed several barriers exist in the student-teacher interaction which creates many obstacles on different levels (educational, psychological, social…). Instructors’ behaviors in class show their unprofessional work and their lack of interest toward their students. In their study, Bahous and Nabhani discovered there is no clear relation between students and their teachers in public schools. For instance, teachers tend to treat their students in harsh ways and disrespect them, which may lead to tension between teachers and students. In addition, Bahous and Nabhani, along with Abouchedid and his colleagues, found out that students in public schools feel uncomfortable with their teachers because their teachers express low expectations towards them. This is opposed to the students’ expectations of themselves which are optimistic and fruitful. The lack of a good relationship between students and teachers leads to a lack of interest in a subject. A research study by Bacha, Bahous, and Nabhani, showed that students were not interested in language subjects since their teachers make them seem boring. To elaborate, Bacha, Bahous, and Nabhani revealed that teachers rarely include any motivational processes that will encourage the students. Rather, they choose to discuss topics they assume will interest the students. This can be considered as a disqualification for some teachers, since the teacher's role is not only to deliver material but also to have a unique and effective way to deliver it.


Online/ Distance Learning

Online Learning is not a new concept in Lebanon. In October 2011, the Ministry of Education launched the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) to improve the quality of education in Lebanon. Awada and Diab defined ICT as an important component in the Lebanese educational system since it allows students to get used to the digital age and benefit from it as much as possible. To specify, Awada and Diab stated the tools of ICT which are computers, tablets, interactive smartboards, and high- speed Internet connection in schools. However, ICT is not implemented in every Lebanese school, especially the public ones since it incurs high costs. Nonetheless, ICT’s usage could have been beneficial during the Coronavirus crisis since learning was shifted from in-class to distance learning. As a result, educational institutions were forced to close and rely on online learning. The research about the effectiveness of online learning by Nguyen found that participants viewed online learning either neutral, positive, or negative with regards to traditional learning. Even though the results were divided into three parts, the majority of the participants (92%) thought that online learning is as beneficial as traditional learning, whereas only 3% preferred traditional learning. The variation between online learning and traditional learning depends on special techniques teachers use. Haidar’s study suggested that teachers might help in making online learning as effective as traditional learning if they tend to use techniques that will help the students in interacting and understanding the information. There are several drawbacks and difficulties students and even teachers might face while participating in online courses. According to Haidar, the possible drawbacks are the slow-speed internet connection, the poor funding in some schools, and most importantly the lack of accreditation of the Lebanese government and the absence of legal composition of online learning. 


Education for Students with Disabilities 

One could start with the following question: should students with disabilities be included in regular classes? The literal meaning of inclusion from the Cambridge dictionary is “the action or state of including or of being included within a group or structure." However, in context to children with disabilities, Vaz et al’s findings defined inclusion as a “concept of social justice; wherein all students are entitled to equal access to all educational opportunities, irrespective of disability or any form of disadvantage." Vaz et al clarified that the vagueness about inclusive learning for students with disabilities is often due to the extent of its good implementation. A study conducted by Mngo showed that about 69% of the teachers in Ontario were unprepared to teach students with disabilities.  Mngo’s study is one of many studies done to check whether teachers and individuals support the concept of inclusion. It showed that about 65.2% of the teachers preferred the inclusive method claiming that their presence in class won’t make it harder for other students to learn and grasp the information easily. In Lebanon, the special education program is implemented in private schools more than in public ones, as stated in El Zein’s research. Lebanon previously separated regular education and special education and made them as independent of each other, El Zein added. Importantly, the parents of students with disabilities were the ones who highlighted the need for a proper special education program in Lebanon. El Zein clarified that a program for inclusion was initiated in the early 90s with the help of teachers, schools (private mainly), and parents in different regions in Lebanon but then stopped because the program came to a halt. Parents had a pleasing attitude towards including their children in regular schools and classes; they also insisted that their children should be included in all levels starting from nursery (or what’s called kindergarten 1 ‘kg1’ today) up till Grade 12, as referred by both Kustantini and El Zein



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        --->    Q&A with Nemer Frayha, Ph.d